Landlord’s appeal against home improvement penalty fails

A private housing landlord which failed to fully insulate a flat before a deadline expired has failed in an appeal against a £3,500 penalty imposed by Crawley Borough Council.

The property above a shop in Gossops Parade is leased by the council to Pi-Gen Pharma, which sublets it as residential accommodation. An inspection by the council in April 2021 resulted in an improvement notice being served on the company.

There were nine elements to the notice, including fitting loft insulation and either central heating or night storage heaters.

Further requirements to conduct a survey on filling cavity walls with insulation and completing any appropriate works were not completed in time.

Pi-Gen Pharma argued at the appeal, heard by a judge and two other panel members earlier this year, that delays caused by contractors being unable to access the property, as well as difficulties securing an approved contractor and obtaining materials, were strong enough reasons to successfully appeal the financial penalty.

However, the panel decided the excuses were not strong enough and agreed that the decision to impose the penalty should be upheld.